Hows this trade?

I give away:


Halladay, Roy SP TOR


·Ortiz, David DH BOS


·Santana, Ervin SP ANA








Iget:


Delgado, Carlos 1B NYM


·Utley, Chase 2B PHI


·Willis, Dontrelle SP FLA





Heres my team:


Barrett, Michael C CHC


Chase Utley


Carlos Delgado


Cabrera, Miguel M. 3B FLA


Hall, Bill SS MIL


Beltran, Carlos CF NYM


Crawford, Carl LF TB


Sheffield, Gary RF DET


Ortiz, David DH BOS


Beckett, Josh SP BOS


Gordon, Tom RP PHI


Dontrelle Willis


Halladay, Roy SP TOR


Hoffman, Trevor RP SD


Maddux, Greg SP SD


Ross, David C CIN


DeRosa, Mark 2B CHC


Rolen, Scott 3B STL


Sosa, Sammy RF TEX


Padilla, Vicente SP TEX


Valverde, Jose RP ARI


Is this trade good or bad for me?


10 team league

Hows this trade?
You gave up waaaay too much pitching for this deal to be good.
Reply:i think that this trade is very even


you are getting the best second basemen in the league, a strong power hitter, and willis who is about to hit his peak while ortiz slowly decreases santana is to young and halladay is just good but your getting alot for it.


i would take this trade in a heartbeat.
Reply:It's a pretty even trade, you are going to get a premier second baseman who is will be exponentially better than Mark DeRosa, giving you all 5 stats. BUT you are also giving up Halladay, who could be AL Cy Young, and Ervin Santana who could break out this year. I like this trade on your end, it seems even, take it if you can.
Reply:Wait a minute- If you are trading for Ortiz using Delgado in that trade then why ar they both on your team right now? You did that for all of them.

chelsea flower show